Saturday, June 24, 2017

Father's Day

We just experienced Father’s Day last week- another creation compliments of the Hallmark Greeting Card Company.  I guess it is supposed to mean something.  Stores promoted sales around it, preachers preached it, and cookies were baked in recognition of it.

In a way it is rather sad.  It shares celebratory acclaim with the likes of Easter and Christmas.  Both of those celebrations occur on one day out of the year and there is considerable build-up to them.  I’m not sure though that Father’s Day is at the same level as Christmas or Easter, but it sure gets it share of commercialization.

Dads have been given a bad rap over the past.  Unlike the old television days of “Father Knows Best”, dads are pretty much portrayed as bumbling idiots, capable of success only by accident.  Even Tim Allen, who always seems to come up with the right answer seems to stumble onto solutions.  I could go into some political explanation here, but I’d prefer to not stir the political pot today.  It would just add to the justification of how men, dads in particular, are incompetent.  

Christmas and Easter aside, I guess dads are supposed to feel special on that day.  I suppose those of us who were recognized for contributing to the gene pool may have felt a moment of pride when someone wished us a Happy Father’s Day, but I think for the most part dads went on like it is just another day.

Don’t get me wrong.  Though my kids are all grown up they still call and send me their best wishes on this day, and I love it.  (We talk on other days, too.)  Unlike the last 20 years, I’ve seen each of my children in the last three weeks, some of them multiple times.  I enjoy the visits with my children.  This year on Father’s Day I got to spend time with some of my grandchildren as well.  That was special for me.  Oh, and don’t forget the chocolate chip cookies.  Father’s Day this year came with nice warm chocolate chip cookies and cookie dough for future consumption.  (Hmmmm.  Consumption.  Didn’t that used to be a disease?)  It is nice to be loved by your children.

And while Father’s Day is a Hallmark creation, I think the hallmark of Father’s Day is guilt.  I have never lived up to the ideal father standard.  I won’t go into any grand explanation.  Suffice it to say that as far as dads go I’m an 80 percenter at best.  I am betting that most dads who are honest with themselves feel pretty much the same way.  I think that most of us can look back and see where we failed.  As for me, I didn’t change very many diapers.  I played catch only a few times.  I missed most of the track meets, wrestling matches, and band concerts.  I wasn’t around to help with homework.  I didn’t go to the parent-teacher conferences.  Though I started out helping with the driving lessons I think I only hit about 50% on that one.  I learned after the fact about first dates.  The deep heart-to-heart conversations only took place when they were in trouble.  Those conversations began with, “Let’s take a walk” or “Let’s go for a walk.”

Let’s take a walk.  Let me share with you the impact that statement had on my kids.  I was with one our daughters the other day with lots of people stirring around.  I just wanted some alone time with her.  I just wanted to be with her and walk around a building with her like a father and daughter.  I wanted her to know that I love her.  HER.  So, I began the invitation with, “Let’s take a walk.”  She immediately thought she was in trouble and sent up those defense antennae.  She’s been on her own for over 20 years now.  I felt like crap.

Most of our children manage to compensate for our failures and succeed in spite of our meager efforts - well, I can only speak for myself; you know, I’m talking about my failures.  My children have managed to succeed in spite of me.  They could not have done better if I had named each of my boys Sue (You know the song by Johnny Cash, “My name is Sue.  How do you do?”).  As I pondered on Father’s Day I couldn’t help but think that perhaps a name change for that day would be appropriate.  I’m thinking it should be Fathers are Proud of their Children’s Day.  We may not measure up to the ideal father, at least I don’t, but our kids certainly live up to my expectation of them.

I’m painfully aware of the fact that there are men out there who have donated their DNA to the creation of a child and that is all they have done.  They do not deserve the title of Father, or even better: Dad.  In fact, some of those men belong in prison for what they have done to their children.  I’ve met many of the fathers and tons of their offspring.  The story is the same.  Their children all believe that no one could have suffered at the hands of a father more than they have.  While their story lines are different, the tortuous outcomes are the same: mental and emotional difficulties, depression, anxiety, PTSD, guilt, shame, years of therapy, and on and on.  These fathers would have done their children a favor by abandoning them.  Enough.


I’m happy to be a father.  But, I don’t need a day of recognition to remind me of my failures as a dad.  I’m happy to have my children tell me that they love me.  I take that to mean that they love me as I am, successes and failures as a father all wrapped up together in a single package.  How about we skip Father’s Day.  Except for the chocolate chip cookies.  Those can come any day.

Sunday, May 21, 2017

Seeking the Spirit through Daily Gospel Habits


Seeking the Spirit through Daily Gospel Habits


In the various callings I’ve had in my gospel experience I’ve sometimes asked myself how it is possible for those who have had the blessings of the gospel can lose their faith and testimony.  I suppose the prophet Lehi considered the same question when he lamented the fate of his posterity when they would reject the Savior.  “But behold, when the time cometh that they shall dwindle in unbelief, after they have received so great blessings from the hand of the Lord—having a knowledge of the creation of the earth, and all men, knowing the great and marvelous works of the Lord from the creation of the world; having power given them to do all things by faith; having all the commandments from the beginning, and having been brought by his infinite goodness into this precious land of promise—behold, I say, if the day shall come that they will reject the Holy One of Israel, the true Messiah, their Redeemer and their God, behold, the judgments of him that is just shall rest upon them” (2 Nephi 1: 10).

While there were many factors that led to the destruction of the Nephite civilization, the root cause of the Nephites’ decline was their loss of faith in Jesus Christ and His gospel.  It was for this very reason that the Book of Mormon writers specifically and repeatedly warned of behaviors and attitudes that weaken faith in the Lord.  Additionally, they continually taught us how to build and strengthen our own testimonies.

Like many bishops and branch presidents, I’ve spent a fair amount of time sitting with members of the Church who are in spiritual danger.  Some have strayed a little while others have managed to pretty much disassociate themselves from the Church.  When addressed early, course corrections are easily made, but when caught in the quicksand of doubt, sin, and indifference many are left alone to face the buffetings of Satan.  So often they don’t recognize that they have lost hope because they simply do not care.  Yet, Hope stands on firm ground reaching out a saving hand to pull them to the safety of the gospel.

Not everyone who comes into the office of the bishop or branch president has given up hope.  Often there are tears and sobs as mistakes are confessed and a path is laid out that will help the repentant person return to full faith and fellowship in the Church and that will open the door for the Holy Ghost to once again be a member’s constant companion.

Dale, however, was a different case for me.  My heart nearly broke when I saw his name appearing on my interview list one evening.  He had recently received a temple recommend so I knew that he was not visiting me for a worthiness interview.  He came from a home where the gospel was taught.  He was a returned missionary and by all accounts, happily married and sealed in the temple.  Expecting the worst, I held my breath when he walked into my office and sat down.  After we exchanged greetings and visited for a minute or two I approached the purpose of his visit.  He could have knocked me over with a feather when he asked what more he could do to improve his spirituality.

I’m sure that you can imagine that I was relieved by his question, yet at the same time my mind raced to give him an answer to his question.  He was already a full tithe payer, lived the Word of Wisdom, attended all his church meetings, sustained his church leaders, lived the law of chastity, and all the other things we ask in the temple recommend interview.  My mind went through the mental checklist of things that we as members of the Church should do.

I cannot tell you how many times I wished as a bishop that I had a Worthiness and Spirituality Prescription Pad that had certain behaviors pre-printed on it so all that I would have to do was to check the appropriate box and sign my name to it.  Such a list would include what seminary students refer to as Standard Mormon Answers – fast, pray, read the scriptures, pay your tithing, attend church, live the Word of Wisdom, render service, attend the temple, and so forth.  Dale was already doing all these things.  But, isn’t it nice to know that these are the things that lead to exaltation in the Celestial Kingdom.

Before we talk about the things we should do to improve our spirituality, it is instructive to know the pitfalls that keep us from achieving the full blessings of the gospel.

King Mosiah pointed to some of the attitudes and behaviors that undermined the faith of his people and can do the same for us.  “NOW it came to pass that there were many of the rising generation that could not understand the words of king Benjamin, being little children at the time he spake unto his people; and they did not believe the tradition of their fathers.  They did not believe what had been said concerning the resurrection of the dead, neither did they believe concerning the coming of Christ.   And now because of their unbelief they could not understand the word of God; and their hearts were hardened.  And they would not be baptized; neither would they join the church.  And they were a separate people as to their faith, and remained so ever after, even in their carnal and sinful state; for they would not call upon the Lord their God” (Mosiah 26:1 - 4).  What we see here is that when people choose not to believe and act on the truths they are taught, their hearts become hardened and therefore they cannot enjoy the blessings of faith and testimony.

There are other attitudes and behaviors that we see among those who choose to not believe.  From the Book of Mormon we learn that some who think they are learned and wise set aside the teachings of the prophets (2 Nephi 9: 28).   Others simply choose to go contrary to the commandments in spite of what they have been taught, thus they lose the Sprit (Mosiah 2: 36-37).  Those who choose this path are given less and less light and knowledge until they know nothing of the mysteries of God.  Consequently, their hearts become hardened, and in the words of Alma, “are taken captive of the devil” (Alma 12: 9-11).  Alma describes other things that people do that lead them away from the truth of the gospel.  They fail to keep the commandments and to pray.  He also says that they fail to “observe the performances of the church” (Alma 31: 8-11).  I find it interesting that Alma identified a difference between the truth of the gospel and the performances of the church and how it is important that we adhere to both.

I have pondered upon those “performances of the church” and just how important they are.  Those performances amount to much more than simply coming to church on Sunday and partaking of the Sacrament, singing a few hymns, and nodding off during Sunday school.  It means saying yes to callings and requests to pray or substitute in a class.  It means getting your teacher-aged son to church 15 or 20 minutes early so he can help prepare the Sacrament.  It means yes to Family Home Evening, personal scripture study, and personal prayers.  It means yes to watching General Conference and participating in stake conference instead of taking the day off.  It means yes to attending and participating in seminary.  It means yes to preparing for and accepting a mission call.  It means yes to sharing the gospel with others on both sides of the veil.  It means yes to sustaining our general, area, and local leaders of the Church, not just by the raising of the hand, but also by saying, “Yes, I will,” then doing it. 

Mormon in his commentary on Amalickiah’s conspiracy to be made king notes how people will succumb to flattering words before they leave the church (Alma 46: 7-8).  We see this pattern several times in the Book of Mormon when flattery is used to draw people away from the gospel and the church.  We see frequent occasions in the Book of Mormon where pride leads to the fall of a chosen people.  We read specifically in Helaman where prideful people withheld their food from the hungry and mocked that which was sacred which led to murder, lying, stealing, plundering, and rising up in great contentions (Helaman 4: 11-13).  Such behavior is evidence of greed and selfishness.  As if to add a capstone to his record, Mormon tells us that those who deny the faith simply do not read the scriptures (Mormon 9: 7-8).

President Henry B. Eyring of the First Presidency of the Church tells a story that relates to the sort of holy habits and righteous routines we should be engaged in.

“Just as truth is given to us line upon line and the light brightens slowly as we obey, even so, as we disobey, our testimony of truth lessens almost imperceptibly, little by little, and darkness descends so slowly that the proud may easily deny that anything is changing.

“I have heard the boast of a man who walked away from the Church slowly. At first he just stopped teaching his Sunday School class, then he stayed away from Church, and then he forgot to pay tithing now and then. … He could not sense the difference, but I could. The light in his eyes and even the shine in his countenance was dimming. He could not tell, since one of the effects of disobeying God seems to be the creation of just enough spiritual anesthetic to block any sensation as the ties to God are being cut. Not only did the testimony of the truth slowly erode, but even the memories of what it was like to be in the light began to seem to him like a delusion” (“A Life Founded in Light and Truth” [Brigham Young University devotional, Aug. 15, 2000], 3, speeches.byu.edu).

So, what can we do to gain spiritual strength and withstand challenges to our faith and testimony?  The Book of Mormon contains gospel principles that can guide individuals who seek to have stronger faith and a stronger testimony.  Nephi gave his people and us a guidepost to follow in maintaining strong faith and testimonies.  “And now behold, I say unto you that the right way is to believe in Christ, and deny him not; and Christ is the Holy One of Israel; wherefore ye must bow down before him, and worship him with all your might, mind, and strength, and your whole soul; and if ye do this ye shall in nowise be cast out” (2 Nephi 25:29).  Simply stated, if we choose to believe in Jesus Christ and worship Him with all our might, mind, and strength, then we will remain spiritually strong and not be cast out.

In answering my question to you about what we can do to gain spiritual strength and withstand the challenges that may assail our faith, the Savior has already given us direction.  “Verily, verily, I say unto you, this is my gospel; and ye know the things that ye must do in my church; for the works which ye have seen me do that shall ye also do; for that which ye have seen me do even that shall ye do; Therefore, if ye do these things blessed are ye, for ye shall be lifted up at the last day.  Therefore, what manner of men ought ye to be?  Verily I say unto you, even as I am” (3 Nephi 27: 21-22, 27).

I would like to return for a moment to my young friend Dale who asked me what more he could do to improve his spirituality.

Elder Lynn G.  Robbins of the Presidency of the Seventy made the following observation.  “Many of us create to do lists to remind us of things we want to accomplish. But people rarely have to be lists. Why? To do’s are activities or events that can be checked off the list when done. To be, however, is never done. You can’t earn checkmarks with to be’s. I can take my wife out for a lovely evening this Friday, which is a to do. But being a good husband is not an event; it needs to be part of my nature—my character, or who I am” (“What Manner of Men and Women Ought Ye to Be?” Ensign or Liahona, May 2011).  So, if we want to improve our spirituality we need to be Christlike in everything we do.

The Savior had prayed to the Father that we would be one with them (John 17: 9-11, 20-23; 3 Nephi 19: 19-23, 28-29).  Not only did He pray for us, but He also taught us how we may be one with Him.

While in Bountiful, the Savior delivered a sermon that was similar to his biblical Sermon on the Mount.  We often refer to the principles he taught as the beatitudes.  You may be interested in knowing that the word beatitude comes from the Latin meaning supreme happiness and is a declaration of blessedness.  Thus, by being poor in spirit, meek, humble, merciful, and having a pure heart, thirsting for justice, being a peacemaker, and standing steadfast in the face of persecution we receive the blessings of heaven (3 Nephi 12 and 13).

Elder D. Todd Christofferson of the Quorum of the Twelve Apostles said, “Jesus achieved perfect unity with the Father by submitting Himself, both flesh and spirit, to the will of the Father. His ministry was always clearly focused because there was no debilitating or distracting double-mindedness in Him. Referring to His Father, Jesus said, ‘I do always those things that please him’ (John 8:29). …

“Surely we will not be one with God and Christ until we make Their will and interest our greatest desire. Such submissiveness is not reached in a day, but through the Holy Spirit, the Lord will tutor us if we are willing until, in process of time, it may accurately be said that He is in us as the Father is in Him” (“That They May Be One in Us,” Ensign, Nov. 2002, 72–73).

Indeed, there are things we can do on a daily basis that will keep us close to the gospel and to the Church, but perhaps a more important question to ask ourselves is what more can we be on a daily basis in order to be one with the Savior and the Father.  After we have kept the commandments; after we have paid our tithing and attended our church meetings and all those other Standard Mormon Answers, might we not want to add to the prescription a list of “be’s”?  Might we not want to be honest, true, chaste, benevolent, kind, peacemakers, meek, humble, forgiving, faithful, and virtuous?  Might we not want to be witnesses of God at all times, and in all things, and in all places?  Compared to keeping the commandments on a daily basis, these are the tough things to be.  These are the life-long attributes that guarantee that the Spirit will be with us always.

I suppose that in a way that it is a matter of obedience for the right reasons, and in this case it truly is a matter of attitude as the Lord “Looketh on the heart” (1 Samuel 16: 7).  I have often spoken of levels of obedience.  When I speak of levels of obedience I like to compare those levels to degrees of glory that we can attain in the next life.

The first level of obedience is a telestial level.  At this stage we obey because we are afraid of the punishment for doing otherwise.  Its root is fear, which is contrary to what the Savior wants.

The second level is a terrestrial level.  Here we obey because we want the reward.  Living in the Celestial Kingdom is appealing to us and we put our whole heart and soul into working for this glory because that is what we want.  We seek the reward.  While working for the reward is good motivation, there is still something better.

The third level of obedience is the celestial level.  It is at this level of obedience that we see a maturation of the human spirit take place.  It is here that we obey simply because we love the Savior and want to please Him.  But there is more, which brings me to the fourth and highest level of obedience.

I refer to this highest level of obedience as an exalted level of obedience.  It is an outgrowth of love for the Savior and is therefore celestial in nature.  And while it is an outgrowth of love for the Savior, there is more.  This level of obedience comes as a result of being one with the Savior and Heavenly Father.  This level is who we are.  It comes to us naturally, not because we are motivated by fear or by reward.  By this I mean to say that we obey because that is who we are.  There is no need to think about doing the right thing because doing the right thing is our true nature and disposition.  As I said, it is who we are, and as others look at you they cannot perceive you doing anything other than the right thing because they trust your actions.  They know you will say yes to the Lord because you are so closely linked to Him that they can nearly see His countenance in your face.

Must we achieve this exalted level of obedience to receive exaltation in the Celestial Kingdom?  I don’t think so, but wouldn’t it be nice if all of us obeyed because that is who we are?  What would our world be like?  What would our communities be like?  What would our families look like?  There would be no disposition to do wrong or harm.  Our thoughts would always turn first to the needs of others.  In this we could literally be one with the Father and the Son.

May we strive for this exalted level of obedience is my prayer in the name of Jesus Christ, amen.



Greene Branch, May 21, 2017

© Gregory B. Talley 2017






Monday, April 17, 2017

Easter 2017

Easter 2017
Susan Talley
What does Easter mean to me?
If I was a reporter, going around the world, asking individuals of different backgrounds and ages, what does Easter mean to you, what would be their response?
Some would say they don’t know who this Jesus is.  Some would say that the stories were out there, but they are made up to make us feel better, to feel some hope in our life.  Others would say there is no Jesus.  Our Christian world would tell you it is one of the holiest days of the year.
Our children might say Easter is about candy, Easter bunnies, and a new outfit for Church.
When our granddaughter, Sarah, was about 2-1/2 years old I was visiting her family.  They had a picture of Jesus hanging in their home.  Whenever I would ask her, “Who is that?”, she would respond, “That is Jesus Christ.”  That Sunday, we attended Church and as the sacrament was being prepared, she looked at me with sad eyes and said, “Jesus Christ died!”  She had been asking her parents about why we take the sacrament.  As they taught her, she was fixed on the message of His death and missed the most important lesson.  She has continued to learn that He indeed died, but that he was resurrected and is now very much alive!
I now am serving in our ward’s nursery.  I love those cute, lovable, energetic children of God, children of families here in our ward.  Today our lesson in Nursery is that Jesus was resurrected and so we will be resurrected after we die.  That is one simple message of Easter.  Our lessons last for 5 minutes if we are lucky.  My desire each Sunday is that they receive one tiny bit of gospel teaching.  If it is longer than that, I lose them completely.
 I remember Easter as a young child.  We would wake up in the morning to find a small basket of Easter candy and a new dress.  But even back then, I knew that Easter was about Jesus Christ.  My father made sure that we knew the meaning of Easter.  When I was younger than some of my nursery children I lost my mother.   My father helped us kids to understand that even though we won’t see her again on this side of the vail, we WILL see her again, because Christ prepared that path and led the way to that new life.
Since those early days, I have continued to learn line upon line, precept upon precept, more about the importance of Easter.  I am sure in the coming years my understanding will continue to increase if I will put effort into learning more about the life of the Savior.  I would like to share a few of those teachings I’ve learned.
On Thursday evening of that week, we know that Christ met with His apostles for the Passover dinner.  One of the events that took place then, continues today.  Christ instituted the sacrament, closing out the Law of Moses, having the people perform blood sacrifices pointing to His coming; and bringing us to the broken heart and contrite spirit to help us show our gratitude for His great gift and our commitment to Him.  I am so grateful that we have the opportunity each Sunday to recommit ourselves to being His followers, to be able to repent and have those sins wiped off our record.
After the Last Supper He went to the Garden of Gethsemane where He prayed to the Father and took upon Himself the sins, pains, trials, and temptations of each of us.  When I look at the pictures that have been painted to represent Christ at this time, He always seems so serene.  I have seen more recent paintings which show Him prostrate on the ground, clutching at the earth, obviously in great agony.  Though I’ve always liked the pictures of Him peacefully praying, I can’t help but wonder what He suffered.  There is no way I can ever thank Him adequately for what He did for me, how many of those stripes were for me.  Then to think of what He has done for my family, for all of you, for everyone.
A series of events took place as He was leaving the Garden.  He was betrayed, arrested, tried, and ultimately sentenced to death.  During this time, He was degraded in some awful ways.  The thought of being spit upon, slapped, and being found guilty of crimes that He was innocent of is something that would be very difficult for me to stand quietly and take.  Our society today seems to allow for more volatile reactions to such behaviors.  What an example of patience He is to me who struggles constantly with my impatience.
After having been beaten and humiliated, even more humiliation was put upon Him.  Crowning Him King of the Jews by placing a crown of thorns upon His head mocking Him, they made Him carry His cross toward the hill where He would be hung.  That added weight to an already weak and hurting body continuing the humiliation until someone stepped in to help by carrying His cross.
He was hung between two common criminals, two thieves.  He continued to suffer on the cross, not for any wrong He had committed, but for us and our sins.  At one point, He was suffering almost more than He could bear.  He asked His Father, “Saying, Father, if thou be willing, remove this cup from me: nevertheless not my will, but thine, be done.” (Luke 22:42) Can you imagine what our Father must have been feeling at this time?  I read a statement by Elder Melvin J. Ballard which has stuck with me.  He stated, (quote) “In that hour I think I can see our dear Father behind the veil looking upon these dying struggles until even He could not endure it any longer, and, like the mother who bids farewell to her dying child and has to be taken out of the room so as not to look upon the last struggles, so He bowed His head and hid in some part of His universe.  His great heart almost breaking for the love that He had for His Son.  Oh, in that moment when He might have saved His son, I thank Him and praise Him that He did not fail us, for He had not only the love of His Son in mind, but He also had love for us.  I rejoice that He did not interfere, and that His love for us made it possible for Him to endure to look upon the suffering of His Son and give Him to us, our Savior and our Redeemer.  Without Him, and without His sacrifice, we would have [been buried in the earth and there our bodies would have] remained, and we would never have come glorified into His presence.  And so this is what it cost, in part, for our Father in Heaven to give the gift of His Son unto men.” (end quote) (Crusader for Righteousness {Salt Lake City: Publishers Press, 1966], p. 137.
On that Easter morn, when Mary Magdalene and the other Mary went to visit the sepulcher to anoint His lifeless body with oil, we know that they found the stone rolled away and that the tomb no longer held His body.  An angel sitting inside told them that He has risen!  The sweetest message they heard that day and that we continue to hear today, He is risen! He alone atoned for our sins and opened the doors to eternity, making it possible for us to live eternally too.
The complete message of the First Easter is the message we hear and know, that because of the Atonement of Jesus Christ, the things He willingly experienced in His time; has blessed all our lives and can continue to bless our lives now and throughout all eternity.
This is not all the messages of Easter, only a partial list.  It is the parts I felt to share with you today.  I want to continue to learn about Christ and His Atonement.  This most pivotal message is the most important message of our lives.  I am so grateful to the Father and to our Savior, Jesus Christ, for allowing this atonement to take place.


Susan Talley, Binghamton Ward, April 16, 2017

Sunday, April 16, 2017

Dimensions of the Atonement of Jesus Christ


“For God so loved the world, that he gave his only begotten Son, that whosoever believeth in him should not perish, but have everlasting life. (John 3:16).”  You’ve seen the scripture reference hundreds of times on televised sporting events.  However, I’m not certain that most of us fully grasp the wide-sweeping meaning of that single verse.
I wish I had begun studying the Atonement of Jesus Christ years ago by only marking my scriptures that referred to this singular important event for mankind.  I think that if I had done so I would have a greater understanding of His Atonement.  However, I also think that if I had done this, I would have the same scriptures marked that I do now.  How does one read the scriptures and not come to the conclusion that every story, every parable, every scene that is played out, and every teaching in the scriptures point to the Atonement of Jesus Christ?
Perhaps you have been like me in studying the scriptures.  As I read and pondered upon them I found comfort, understanding, peace, and great teachings and principles by which to live.  The scriptures are replete with celestial ideals for living.  But, doing so makes them nothing more than field books for living.  Yes, they become our Liahona pointing the way back to Heavenly Father, but that only encompasses a terrestrial level of obedience.  However, if we look at the teachings in the scriptures as a type of things to come as Alma taught, we then begin to unlock the power of His Atonement (Alma 33: 19).  We come to understand what the Apostle Paul said when he taught that all the hidden treasures and knowledge are a shadow of things to come (Colossians 2: 3, 17).
As we think of His Atonement we tend to think of two marvelous and important miracles. Specifically, we teach that we are punished for our own sins and not for Adam’s transgression and that through the Atonement of Jesus Christ all mankind may be saved by obedience to the laws and ordinances of the gospel (Articles of Faith 1: 1 – 2).  Herein is what may be referred to as saving principles of the gospel. 
To understand His Atonement, we must look first to our pre-mortal existence for that is where it began.  It was there where we participated in a council and selected a course of action.  It was there that we accepted a plan to enter mortality and be allowed the opportunity to exercise agency.  It was there that we understood we would be tested and be proven worthy to return to live in the presence of God through eternity (Abraham 3: 24-26).  It was also there that we understood all would sin and come short of the glory of God (Romans 3: 23).  And it was there that the Savior said it was His work and His glory to bring to pass the immortality and eternal life of man (Moses 1: 39).  Elder Jeffrey R. Holland of the Quorum of the Twelve Apostles taught “The Atonement was the foreordained but voluntary act of the Only Begotten Son of God in which He offered His life and spiritual anguish as a redeeming ransom for the effect of the Fall of Adam upon all mankind and for the personal sins of all who repent” (March 2008 Ensign).

Overcoming Physical Death

The act of the Atonement we celebrate this day is the resurrection of all the dead from the grave.  The Apostle Paul explained that as we are planted in death like Christ that we will also be raised in His likeness in the resurrection (Romans 6: 5).  He also taught, “For as in Adam all die, even so in Christ shall all be made alive (1 Corinthians 15:22).  Peter taught that Christ has “begotten us again unto a lively hope of (His) resurrection (1 Peter 1: 3).  Again as Paul taught, Christ risen from the dead became the firstfruits of them that slept” (Corinthians 15:20).

Overcoming Spiritual Death

We also believe that another act of the Atonement took place in the Garden of Gethsemane in addition to the cross.  Luke records in his gospel that Christ “being in an agony…prayed more earnestly: and his sweat was as it were great drops of blood falling down to the ground” (Luke 22: 44).  King Benjamin speaking of the Atonement testified that “he shall suffer temptations, and pain of body, hunger, thirst, and fatigue, even more than man can suffer, except it be unto death; for behold, blood cometh from every pore, so great shall be his anguish for the wickedness and the abominations of his people” (Mosiah 3: 7).  Nephi testified that Christ continued to suffer for our sins when He was lifted up on the cross” (1 Nephi: 11: 33).  Again, Elder Holland explains that “To…meet the demands of the Atonement, the sinless Christ went into the Garden of Gethsemane…to bear the agony of soul only He could bear.”

Salvation of those Who Died without Knowledge

There are other aspects of the Atonement that we seldom consider and often overlook.  The Apostle Paul speaking to the Saints at Corinth said, “If in this life only we have hope in Christ, we are of all men most miserable” (1 Cor. 15: 19).  As we read this scripture we tend to focus on a teaching that we can have hope in Christ not only in this life, but also in the life to come.  While this is a true principle, if you shift the emphasis of the wording of Paul’s teaching you discover another true principle.  Consider Paul’s message when we read it as follows: “If in this life only we have hope in Christ, we are of all men most miserable.”  In other words, hope in Christ is available not only for us, the living who have had the opportunity to hear, see, or learn the words of Christ in this life, but is available for all mankind, including those who never had the opportunity to know of Christ.  Paul hinted at this when speaking of the Atonement to the Romans when he taught that “until the law sin was in the world: but sin is not imputed when there is no law” (Romans 5: 13).  In other words, where there is no law sin cannot be attributed, ascribed, or assigned to those who do not have the law.
We understand, of course, that “for this cause was the gospel preached also to them that are dead, that they might be judged according to men in the flesh, but live according to God in the spirit” (Peter 4:6).  This understanding of the Atonement rests at the foundation of our reason for seeking out our kindred dead and performing ordinances necessary for their exaltation.

Redemption of Little Children

A fourth aspect of His Atonement is the salvation of little children who die before the age of accountability.
Mormon in his epistle to his son Moroni spoke of the “gross error” (Moroni 8: 6) that exists in the teaching of the necessity of baptizing little children.  He explains that those who believe little children need to be baptized are in the “gall of bitterness” (Moroni 8: 14).  Mormon continued his epistle by teaching repentance and baptism were reserved for those who are accountable and capable of committing sin and that little children are alive in Christ.  Further, he said that those who teach that baptism is necessary for little children deny the mercies of Christ (Moroni 8: 10, 12, & 20).

Pains, Afflictions, and Temptations

The prophet Isaiah spoke of yet another dimension of the Atonement when in speaking of the coming Messiah he said that “he hath borne our griefs, and carried our sorrows” (Isaiah 53: 4).  King Benjamin taught of the coming Savior when he said Christ would “suffer temptations, and pain of body, hunger, thirst, and fatigue, even more than man can suffer” (Mosiah 3: 7).  And finally, Alma in speaking to the people of Gideon said, “…he shall go forth, suffering pains and afflictions and temptations of every kind; and this that the word might be fulfilled which saith he will take upon him the pains and the sicknesses of his people.  And he will take upon him death, that he may loose the bands of death which bind his people; and he will take upon him their infirmities, that his bowels may be filled with mercy, according to the flesh, that he may know according to the flesh how to succor his people according to their infirmities” (Alma 7:11 - 12).
As I have pondered upon these verses it has occurred to me that if He has suffered pains and afflictions and temptations of every kind there must be evidence of those sufferings in the scriptures.  And so I turned to the New Testament to do a brief search to satisfy my curiosity.  What I found was over one-hundred examples of when He suffered pains, afflictions, and temptations of every kind.  For example, during His lifetime He was:

Abandoned
Accused of Blasphemy
He was Accused of Keeping Bad Company
And Wrongly Accused of Evil or Doing Something Bad
He was Beaten, Hit, Injured, Struck by Another                               
He became Angry
He was Betrayed
Caught in a Storm
Conspired Against
Criticized because of the Company He Kept
He dealt with Quibbling
Others Failed to Thank Him
He had Faithless Followers
He dealt with the death of a close friend and family member
He was Denied
Disappointed and
Left Alone to Face a Huge Task while Others Slept
He was Forsaken
Hungry                                                                                               
Thirsty
Hated
And Homeless
He Suffered Indignities in front of Loved Ones
Laughed at
Mocked
Many Murmured Against Him
Many did not believe Him
He was misunderstood
Persecuted
His motives and authority were questioned
He was Rejected by His Own Community                                       
He was Reviled
Scourged
Shamed and
Spit Upon
He was Willing to Subject Himself to Someone Else’s Authority
He faced temptation
He was Passed Over for Someone Less Qualified than He was
He was Wearied and Tired
Stripped of His Belongings
He associated With People Who Couldn’t Keep Up with Him
He was Tasked with a Cross
Nailed to a Cross                                                                               
He did the Unpleasant and
Associated with the Unpleasant
And He was Unemployed
Additionally, He
Provided Direction and Instruction
Increased in Wisdom and Stature
Dealt with Popularity
He Preached
Selected Followers
Sent Followers into Harm’s Way and
Taught with Authority
Took Charge of the Ward Dinner for thousands of people and not just once
Held a Personal Priesthood Interview

·       He was indeed “despised and rejected of men; a man of sorrows, and acquainted with grief:” (Isaiah 53:3)

Strengthening and Enabling Power

Elder David A. Bednar of the Quorum of the Twelve Apostles speaks of the strengthening and enabling power of the Atonement of Jesus Christ as he taught that it is “one thing to know that Jesus Christ came to the earth to die for us….But we also need to appreciate that the Lord desires, through His Atonement and by the power of the Holy Ghost, to live in us—not only to direct us but also to empower us” (BYU Devotional, Oct. 23, 2001).  Consider the following examples from the Book of Mormon.
Nephi in his prayer said, “wilt thou deliver me from the hands of my brethren; yea, even give me strength that I may burst these bands with which I am bound” (Nephi 7:17).  Rather than praying to be released from the binding that held him he prayed for strength to overcome those bonds.  Remember when Alma and his people were persecuted by Amulon that “it came to pass that the burdens which were laid upon Alma and his brethren were made light, yea, the Lord did strengthen them that they could bear up their burdens with ease” (Mosiah 24: 14-15).  Rather than removing the burdens from Alma and his people, the Lord gave them strength which made the burdens lighter.  Or, when Alma prayed while he was in prison he said, “O Lord, give us strength according to our faith which is in Christ, even unto deliverance” (Alma 14: 26).  We see later when Alma prayed that he would have strength that he would “suffer with patience” the afflictions that would come upon him (Alma 31: 31).
In the Old Testament David acknowledged that God was his strength and power: and made his way perfect (Samuel 22:33).  Isaiah taught that the Lord gives power to the faint; and an increase in strength to those who have no might (Isaiah 40:29).  In speaking to the Corinthians as to why the Lord gives men weaknesses and the grace that he had received from Christ, Paul stated that his strength was made perfect in weakness and that he would rather glory in his infirmities that the power of Christ would rest upon him (2 Corinthians 12: 9).
The Lord can provide strength to us in those times of physical or temporal need, but we would be mistaken if we believed that it happens all the time.  We would not; however, be mistaken to believe that the Lord will consistently give us strength and power to overcome spiritual hazards of life. Without question, He has empowered us to act and not be acted upon (2 Nephi 2: 13-14, 26).

Grace

There are other aspects of the Atonement of Jesus Christ such as the fulness of joy that is promised to us not only in the life to come but for the here and now.  None, however, would be meaningful without at least a passing mention of grace.  We teach that “Our sins make us unclean and unfit to dwell in God’s presence, and we need His grace to purify and perfect us “after all we can do” (2 Nephi 25: 23, True to the Faith).  I think that sometimes we place too much emphasis on the “all we can do” part of Nephi’s teachings and pay too little attention to His grace.  The fact of the matter is that we will never be capable of achieving a celestial level of glory without the Savior lifting and pulling us up.  He did not have to accept this role.  Just as each of us has the agency to choose, He also had His agency, and He chose to be the Mediator, the Savior.  Only He chose to accept the weight of the names Wonderful, Counselor, The Mighty God, The Everlasting Father, the Prince of Peace (Isaiah 9: 6), and to be King of Kings and Lord of Lords (Rev. 19: 16).  Without Him there is no hope.  He is our hope.

© 2017 Gregory B. Talley, Binghamton Ward, April 16, 2017


Monday, December 12, 2016

The Other Wise Man

The Story of the Other Wise Man
Henry van Dyke
as told (more or less) by Dad

Introduction for my Children


            “The Story of the Other Wise Man” has been a traditional story included in the Schofield Christmas Family Home Evening for several years.  The first time I heard it though, was when my mother told the story at church.  I was a young boy at the time, struggling in my own mind to find the true meaning of Christmas.  But, it was when I heard my mother tell the story that I came a little closer to understand.  I had not heard the story again until our Christmas in Los Alamos when Grandpa Schofield asked me to tell the second half of the story in the Family Home Evening.
            As I read the story in preparation for Family Home Evening I concentrated on learning the details of the story because I did not want to have to read it.  I am not sure if I got the details right or not, but as I told the story, it came alive to me.  I saw Artaban in my own mind as if I was having the dream that Van Dyke was telling.  Ever since that time when I recount the story I remember it as though it was my own dream.  Remember, however, that it is only a story.  It is not a true story, but the message is as truthful as eternity is long.

The Story


I

            Everybody knows the story of the three wise men, how they traveled to take their gifts and worship the new Christ child.  This is the story of the Other Wise Man who also saw the star and spent a lifetime following where it led.
            I first met Artaban in the Hall of Dreams, a place in the heart.  I saw him in his palace near the mountains of Persia.  He stood at the gate welcoming his friends to his home as they came one by one at his invitation to hear him speak of something he had discovered.  After they arrived they sat around a fire that danced in the night.  Once again he welcomed his nine guests who were all dressed in traditional clothing of nobles.
            “I have asked you to come this evening to invite you to come on a journey with me.  Three other friends of mine and I have looked to the stars and the wonders in heaven.  We have also read the books of prophecy in which the future is foretold in words that are hard to understand.  The words of the prophecy and the stars in heaven tell us that a miracle is about to happen.  A king is to be born who will come out of Israel and he will save all mankind.  I have sold all my possessions and have taken the money and purchased these.”
            Artaban reached inside his vest and removed a small leather bag and opened it.  He then poured out three precious stones into his hand—a sapphire, deep blue as the dark of night; a ruby, red as the red of fire; and a pearl, white as the fresh fallen snow.
            “A new star will appear in the heavens, and when it does, my companions and I will meet to travel together across the desert.  The signs in the heavens tell me that the time is near.  Come with me that you too, can worship this King of the Jews.”
            One by one his friends told him that he was silly to search after a king that would come from the Jews, or that they were too old to make the trip, or had businesses that they could not afford to leave.  One by one, they had a reason why they could not follow until Artaban stood alone with his father.
            “My son, it may be the light of truth that you follow or it may be a hollow dream.  But, it is better to follow the shadow of the best than to remain content with the worst.  I am too old for this journey, but my heart shall be your companion.  Go in peace.”
            Artaban now stood alone.  The embers of the fire now were a but a dull glow in the dark.  As he looked into the heavens in deep thought he spied the glimmer of a new star.  The time had arrived.  Artaban must now make his journey.

II

            Vasda, Artaban’s faithful horse, seemed to sense his master’s excitement.  For the next ten days they would travel over 500 miles to meet the other Magi.  It was a long and dangerous trip and they would have to pace themselves carefully to make the distance on time.  There would be no time to spare if they were to meet at the appointed temple on time.
            On the last day of the journey, Vasda was tired and weak.  Artaban and Vasda could easily have stopped to rest, but they were only three hours away from the Temple of the Spheres and they had to be there by midnight in order to make the journey across the desert with Artaban’s friends.  As they traveled on, Vasda seemed to sense danger off to the side of the road.  He carefully moved forward, prepared to take his master to safety.  As they pressed on, Artaban saw the form of a man off to the side of the road.  He lay on the ground and was dressed as one of the poor Hebrews who was in exile.  Artaban dismounted and walked closer to the man.  He was taken with fever and deathly ill.  Artaban supposed he would die in the night and started back to his horse.  As he turned, a hand reached up and grabbed Artaban’s robe.  He then heard a plea for help.
            Artaban was a gifted Magi and was skilled in the healing arts.   He thought of his duty to heal but thought that if he lingered only an hour that he would miss his appointment with his fellow travelers.  They would leave him behind believing that he had given up on the trip and he would miss seeing this new king of the Jews.  “God or purity and truth, tell me what I should do.”  Artaban then pulled his healing herbs from his cloak and gave the dying man water and sat and ministered unto him through the night.
            Much past midnight, the Hebrew awakened and asked his healer who he was and what he was doing.  Artaban answered the man, telling him that he was in search of the new Christ child, the King of the Jews.  The man, much stronger now said, “I have nothing to repay thee for making me whole.  I can tell you only this.  Our traditions say that this king of the Jews will be born not in Jerusalem, but in Bethlehem.  May the God of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob guide you safely there.
            Artaban and Vasda left the man in the care of an innkeeper and rushed towards the temple, but the morning rays of the sun told him that he was much too late to meet with his friends.  When he arrived at the temple he saw that he was right.  His fellow travelers had left, but had left a note under a rock for Artaban.  “We have waited as long as we can.  We press forward and hope you can join us.”
            Artaban was stunned.  There was no way that he would be able to make the journey alone.  He must sell the sapphire for a train of camels and supplies to make the trip across the desert alone.

III

            As Artaban traveled across the desert his heart was filled with guilt as he had taken one of the gifts for the newborn Messiah and sold it for provisions to cross the desert.  Still, he had two gifts remaining and perhaps the king would find those gifts acceptable.
            Artaban arrived in Bethlehem three days after the other three wise men had brought their gifts to the child of Mary and Joseph.  But, they had already gone and he was left alone to find the Christ child and present him with his ruby and pearl.  As he searched the streets for someone to give him directions he sensed an unusual quiet.  Finally, he heard a voice of a young mother singing to her crying baby.  He knocked on the door and was met by the young woman.  He told her why he was there and she replied, “Three days ago three men came from the east bearing gifts to a child who was born.  Angels sang at the child’s birth and shepherds came to pay tribute to the child, but just as quickly as they came, they disappeared so into the night.  Joseph and Mary fled from the town and have gone to Egypt.  Ever since then, there has been a spell upon the city and something evil lingers here.”
            Artaban stood in despair as he thought how he had missed giving his gift to the child.  As he stood in the doorway, he heard a terrible clamor from the streets of the city.  Suddenly, there were soldiers marching through the streets with bloodied swords.  Mothers ran screaming through the streets as the soldiers ransacked the homes, killing all the newborn children.  Artaban turned to the young mother and sent her to the back of the house to keep her child still.  Soon, the captain of the soldiers approached the house and Artaban stood in the doorway blocking his entrance.  “Step aside!” commanded the soldier.
            “There is no child here,” replied Artaban, then reached into his purse and pulled the ruby from it.  He stretched forth his hand and said, “This is the precious gift for the prudent captain who passes and leaves this house in peace.”  The captain of the guard turned to the soldiers and commanded, “Move on.  There is no child here,” then snatched the ruby and marched on.
            Artaban stood alone in the doorway, now trembling.  “What have I done?  I have spoken an untruth, though it was to save the life of a child.  But, now I have lost two of the gifts for the King of the Jews.  What ever shall I do?  How will I ever be worthy to see thy face?”
            But the tearful voice of the young mother spoke, “Because thou hast saved the life of my child, may the Lord bless thee and keep thee; the Lord make His face to shine upon thee and be gracious unto thee….”

IV

            I followed Artaban in my dreams as he traveled through the years looking for the Christ child.  Everywhere he went it seemed that people needed his healing powers.  There were those in need—those who were hungry and thirsty or cold in the night.  There were others in prison, alone.  Each time after he stopped he would learn that he had just missed seeing this great King of the Jews.  Still, he journeyed on in hopes of giving his final gift to the Messiah.
            Thirty-three years had passed since he began his journey.  His hair was now pure white, his eyes were tired, and he was slow in his walk.  He knew his time on earth was short as he made his journey once again into Jerusalem.  It was the time of the Passover and there were many strangers in the town, but there seemed to be a certain agitation among the people there.  Soon he saw a crowd of people moving towards the outskirts of town.  He joined them in their movement and asked a stranger where they were going.
            “Haven’t you heard?  We are going to Golgotha where two famous robbers are to be crucified along with another man called Jesus of Nazareth.  This Jesus has done many great works among the people, but the elders say he must die because he claimed to be the Son of God and King of the Jews.”
            The words sank deep into Artaban’s heart.  Could it be that this is the king he had sought for over three decades?  His heart pounded as he thought on his final gift.  Perhaps his visit to the King of the Jews had been delayed all these years so that he might ransom him with his remaining gift—the pearl.  Quickly, Artaban pressed onward to Golgotha to rescue Jesus with his gift.

V

            As Artaban moved with the crowd he saw a troop of soldiers dragging a young girl with a torn dress and disheveled hair.  As he looked down at her in compassion she broke a hand free and reached up to him and threw herself at his feet.  “Have pity on me.  I am a daughter of the true religion which is taught by the Magi.  My father was a merchant and has died and I am being sold as a slave to pay his debts.  Save me from a fate worse than death.”
            Artaban trembled.  It was the same dilemma that he had faced before.  It was the conflict between the expectation of faith and the demonstration of love.  Twice before he had been called upon to spend the gifts for the Messiah in the aid of others. Was this his great opportunity or his final trial?  Only one thing was certain.  To ignore the plea from the young girl would indeed be a fate worse than death.  To rescue her would be a true act of love.  But, what of the Messiah?
            Slowly, he reached into his leather pouch and pulled from it the pearl.  Over the years the pearl had taken on a luster of the sapphire and ruby that had once been its traveling companions.  In his hand he held the ransom for the King or the girl.  He could not save both.  He handed it to the soldier in charge and commanded him to release the girl.
            As he spoke the sky began to darken and a terrible groan came from the earth.  The walls of the buildings began to tremble and rocks fell to the earth.  Dust filled the air and the soldiers ran in terror.  Artaban and the young girl huddled together next to a wall for safety, but a falling tile struck Artaban on the temple, knocking him nearly unconscious. 
He lay breathless with his head resting on the shoulder of the young girl.  She thought Artaban appeared to be listening to something, but could not tell what it was.  His lips trembled, then moved to form words.  “No, no, it is not true.”
Still, the young girl could not hear the other voice, but knew that Artaban was surely talking to someone other than her.  “Not so, my Lord: For when saw I thee an hungered and fed thee? Or thirsty, and gave thee drink?  When saw I thee a stranger, and took thee in?  Or naked, and clothed thee?  When saw I thee sick or in prison, and came unto thee?  Three-and-thirty years have I looked for thee; but I have never seen thy face, nor ministered to thee, my King.”
He ceased his speech, and now the young woman heard a voice in the distance, sweet and pure as caroling music.  Now she understood the words:
“Verily I say unto thee, Inasmuch as thou hast done it unto one of the least of these my brethren, thou hast done it unto me.”

A calmness came over Artaban’s face.  There was a long, last breath.  His journey was over.  His treasures were accepted.  The Other Wise Man had found the King.

Saturday, December 10, 2016

Fairness of the Electoral College

The Electoral College presents us with some rather fascinating presidential election results especially as one looks at those results in comparison with popular votes and winners and losers.  Our 2016 election has many asking the validity of the Electoral College.  There is likely to be angst when a candidate loses by a narrow margin, but when one wins the popular vote but loses the Electoral College anger, though fueled by misunderstanding, is probably justified.

The 2016 presidential election results are not without precedence.  Twice in history we have seen the popular vote-getter lose the Electoral College.  In 1876 Rutherford B. Hayes (R) won only 48.47% of the popular vote but won the Electoral College by attaining 50.1%, and thus the presidency (4,034,311 popular votes to Samuel J. Tilden’s [D] 4,288,546 popular votes).  Then of course most of us remember the 2000 General Election when George W. Bush (R) attained only 49.74% of the popular vote but won the presidency with 50.47% in the Electoral College (50,455,156 popular votes to Albert Gore, Jr. [D] 50,992,335 popular votes).  Incidentally, one could reasonably ponder upon the effect of third-party candidates on popular votes in individual states and the resultant impact they have on the electoral vote.
 


Table 1
Presidential Elections where Electoral College Votes were Greater than Popular Vote
 


Year
President
Percent Popular Vote
Percent Electoral College
1876
Rutherford B. Hayes
48.47%
50.1%
2000
George W. Bush
49.74%
50.47%
2016
Donald J. Trump
48.97%
56.88%


It is worth noting here that there was one time in our history that a presidential election was not determined by popular vote or by the Electoral College.  In 1824 neither John Quincy Adams nor Andrew Jackson received a majority of the Electoral College votes to win the presidency.  One-hundred, thirty-one (131) Electoral College votes were required to win.  John Quincy Adams had received 84 Electoral College votes and Andrew Jackson received 99 of the 131 votes needed.  Adams also receive 113,122 popular votes and Andrew Jackson received 151, 271 popular votes.  There were a sufficient number of Electoral College votes that went to William Harris Crawford (41) and Henry Clay (37) to prevent either Adams or Jackson to claim victory.  Therefore, the Twelfth Amendment came into play and the election was handed over to the House of Representatives, which selected Adams as the President of the United States.

Andrew Jackson (D) was not to be denied the Presidency.  His turn would come in 1828 and again in 1832.  It is the 1832 election that will serve as our first example of how a lopsided victory can be attained by means of the Electoral College.  See Table 2.  In this election, Jackson won 59% of the popular vote defeating Henry Clay (N-R) in the Electoral College with nearly 82% of the electoral votes.  In 1844 James K. Polk (D) won 50.12% of the popular vote and 61.82% of the electoral vote, defeating his opponent Henry Clay (W).  Then there was the election of 1864 wherein Abraham Lincoln won only 55% of the popular vote but won nearly 91% of the electoral votes.

In 1892 Grover Cleveland (D) won 50.13% of the popular vote, defeating Benjamin Harrison (R) with 65% of the electoral votes.  Franklin Roosevelt (D) won 59% of the popular vote in 1932 but won 89% of the electoral votes, defeating Herbert Hoover (R).  Roosevelt followed that victory in 1936 by winning 27,757,333 votes (nearly 62% of the popular votes) over Alfred M. Landon (R) who received 16,684,231 and took just 8 electoral votes.  Franklin did it again in 1940 by taking almost 54% of the popular vote, but defeating Thomas Dewey (R) by taking over 81% of the electoral votes.

Lyndon Johnson (D) in 1964 pulled in 61% of the popular vote over Barry Goldwater (R) but took in a whopping 90% of the Electoral College.  And of course we have Barack Obama (D), who in 2012 only took in 52% of the popular vote but won the election over Mitt Romney (R) by taking in nearly 62% of the electoral votes.
 


Table 2
Sample of Percentage of Popular Votes vs. Percentage of Electoral College Votes
 


Year
President
Percent of Population
Percent of Electoral Vote
Opponent
1828
Andrew Jackson (D)
56.19
68.20
John Quincy Adams
1844
James K. Polk (D)
50.12
61.82
Henry Clay
1864
Abraham Lincoln (R)
55.03
90.99
George B. McClellan
1892
Grover Cleveland (D)
51.74
65.64
Benjamin Harrison
1932
Franklin Roosevelt (D)
59.16
88.89
Herbert C. Hoover
1936
Franklin Roosevelt (D)
62.46
98.49
Alfred M. Landon
1940
Franklin Roosevelt (D)
55.00
84.56
Wendell L. Wilkie
1964
Lyndon B. Johnson (D)
61.34
91.33
Barry M. Goldwater
2012
Barack H. Obama (D)
51.96
61.71
Mitt Romney

 

Over the last 49 presidential elections since the 1824 presidential election between John Quincy Adams and Andrew Jackson, 54.81% of the popular vote went to the winner while 71.62% of the Electoral College votes went to the winning candidate.  (Popular vote data were not available prior to the 1824 presidential election.)

Perhaps it is the thinking that the electoral votes should be in proportion to the popular votes that disturbs everyone.  By the way, the examples given here are merely examples of many of the elections we have endured through our history.  While there are a few elections that appear somewhat proportional between the popular vote and the electoral vote on the surface, not a single one is, and most are wildly out of proportion.  Anyway, it may be the thinking that electoral votes should be in proportion to the popular vote that is unsettling with many.  Essentially, what proponents of a proportionate relationship are saying is that the majority should rule.  Depending upon who you listen to, the Founding Fathers were wise in setting up the Electoral College in guaranteeing that a majority not trample on the minority (consider Tocqueville’s thoughts on majority rule and minority rights). 

Another way to look at it is that ten states have more than 50% of the total U.S. population.  If we had a majority rule, these ten states could be the tail that wags the dog.  They could decide the fate of the other 40 states again and again.  Where, one might ask – or should ask, the fairness is in this arrangement.  But, it doesn’t happen because these ten states have a total of 236 electoral votes in a system that currently requires 270 electoral votes of the 538 votes available to win.
 


Table 3
Ten Most Populous States and their Electoral College Votes
 



State
Population
Electoral Votes
1
California
37,253,956
53
2
Texas
25,145,561
36
3
New York
19,378,102
27
4
Florida
18,801,310
27
5
Illinois
12,830,632
18
6
Pennsylvania
12,702,379
18
7
Ohio
11,536,504
16
8
Georgia
9,687,653
14
9
Michigan
9,883,640
14
10
North Carolina
9,535,483
13
Total

166,755,220
236
Total US

308,745,538
538
10 State % of US Population and Electoral College
54.01%
43.87%


Note that these 10 states make up 20% of the total number of states in the Union.  Making up 54% of the total U.S. population creates a scenario where these states could always determine the outcome of a presidential election, leaving the other 80% of the states without a voice and thus negating the doctrine of states rights.  By using the Electoral College a presidential candidate must garner electoral votes from other less populous states in order to win.  Likewise, it makes it nearly impossible to win the presidency by not capturing at least some of these ten states.

The Electoral College is not the only example in government that we have relative to majority rule vs. minority rights.  In order to avoid the “tyranny of the majority”, a three-fifth vote is required to end a senate filibuster.  Such a supermajority gives ear to the minority.  Of course this does not absolutely guarantee the right for the minority to be heard, but it requires 60% of that body to bring an end to a filibuster.  The other thing that recognizing minority rights is that it encourages parties to work together.  One never knows as a majority member when you will end up in the minority.  Keep in mind Madison’s observation that in a pure democracy decisions are not always decided by “the rules of justice and the rights of the minor party, but by the superior force of an interested and overbearing majority.”  Everyone has heard the history lesson given by John Adams that democracies self-implode.

Remember that we have two houses of congress.  The President can veto legislation passed by both the House and the Senate, but two-thirds of those bodies can override that veto.  Minority rights are further protected (to some extent) in the way we amend the Constitution.  The Constitution requires a two-thirds vote of both Houses and three-fourths of the state legislatures to amend the Constitution.  While not perfect, at least some protection is guaranteed the minority population by requiring such an overwhelming majority to amend the Constitution.  Otherwise, 50.1% could always rule the roost.  I am not a proponent of abortion rights; however, consider this as a safety valve in the way we function as a nation when it comes to such issues as a woman’s right to have an abortion.

Perhaps the ultimate protection of minority rights is the Bill of Rights.  While we tend to ask questions such as why the police don’t just run in and do their job or how in the world a judge could dismiss charges against a person on a technicality when a person is clearly guilty, people tend to appreciate those minority protections when they are faced with the police at their door.


The Founding Fathers were painfully aware that a pure democracy would lead to the same oppression that we had fought to get out from under.  This should be evident not only by the creation of the Electoral College, but also the inclusion of the Bill of Rights into our Constitution, how amendments are added to that document, and how bills may become (or not become) laws.  It just might be wise to sit back and take a look at the big picture before any serious move is made to do away with the Electoral College.